Got Design Questions?

peaman

Sustaining Member
I am not understanding this statement. Semantics, perhaps. The forces from the shrouds are taken directly down to the TAFG by large-diameter SS Navtec rods, and some internal bulkhead connections. (Depending on EY model.)
The deck, while it may have some additional reinforcement, is for the most part structurally neutral with respect to the shrouds. My point is that moving the shrouds outboard will impose lateral loads at the deck level, while in the original configuration, lateral loads are lower in the hull, well below the deck.
 

Dave G.

1984 E30+ Ludington, MI
From a purely performance point of view decreasing the upwind/pointing ability of the boat makes zero sense to me. As others have said it would also take major redesign and structural changes to both the hull and the rig.
 

TLEO

Student of Life
The 32-3 stays are actually easy to inspect, and giving up the close sheeting angle would be a step backwards in time.
I wanted to thank everyone for their knowledge, It was a crazy blonde question I asked my husband who thought I should ask the group. Not stepping backwards, i guess there are stupid questions.
 

frick

Member III
I did see an E29 with the Chain plates moved to the hull. It looked good.
What I wonder, as an old Racer, Does it mess up jib sheets, meaning that you can not point as high.
 

Pete the Cat

Sustaining Member
I did see an E29 with the Chain plates moved to the hull. It looked good.
What I wonder, as an old Racer, Does it mess up jib sheets, meaning that you can not point as high.
Probably it will mess up the sheeting angle, but it might not be that critical depending on the jib, angle of attack, and the general sailing characteristics of boat--if the boat points poorly, it won't matter much. I am mystified why anyone would abandon the careful structural design of most production boats and move chainplates outboard. You understand that these are under incredible pressure when underway and you would need to ensure that load is properly transferred to the rest of the vessel's structures--this generally means fastening chainplates to bulkheads or knees that transfer the load widely to the hull. This is not a DIY thing for amateurs imho.
 
Top