I am considering the Lofrans Manual. My E-38 has the original shallow locker, maybe 6" tops, so there would be a lot of manual moving the chain in the locker in addition to manual cranking of the windlass. How do you like the retrieval rate of the manual? I think the manual is attractive because an electric would never work without installing a new locker with sufficient fall.
This might help answer some questions. A video from my YouTube page, which has had over 11k views, showing me deploy and retrieve the anchor.
I shot this while in my slip so it's not a true representation of real life but I've been using the Lofrans Manual for a few years now and haven't regretted it. I too didn't want to do a major refit of the anchor locker to accommodate an electric windless because I didn't see real benefit in spending the time and money required to do it properly. I anchor but not that often so the occasional use of a manual windlass is not big deal. I've pulled my anchor out last week after it was deeply embedded in Chesapeake mud and it was no problem. I also have a wash down hose in my anchor locker, that sucks up bay water, and it works well with the manual windlass in that I can really take my time in washing off the mud. It's not as fast as an electric, of course, but it's very reliable. My E32-3 has a very deep anchor locker which is really more of an anchor "bucket" because its a formed insert that does OK with holding the chain but wouldn't accommodate an electric because it's to flimsy. To help the chain feed into the locker I also installed a small anchor roller in the well and a thick block of teak under the windlass to raise the chain up so it clears the edge of the anchor locker.
Here the link to my blog on how I installed the Lofrans Manual Windlass:
https://ericsonyachts.org/ie/ubs/installing-a-manual-windlass-on-a-e32-3.982/
MORE INFO:
I looked back into my archives and retrieved part of a video about an anchorage I visited on the bay last year and it shows a more real world view of the Lofrans Windlass being used.