CA Bottom Paint Vs. 49 other states?
Don,
In year 2000, Trinidad SR (Slime Reduction) bottom paint was not available here in CA. (I couldn't buy it anyway). So, what to do? I was in NJ and purchased 2 gallons of Trinidad SR and sent it out to CA. Amazingly enough, purchasing 2 gallons of Trinidad SR, (which weighd about 30 lbs each) and shipping it to CA from NJ was still cheaper that buying regular Trinidad paint here in CA. Note: Trinidad paint was on bottom when I purchased boat, so I stuck with it.
Now SR is available here in CA, but here's my observations given avergage use of about twice a month in summer and maybe once a month in winter over the course of two applications:
NJ Trinidad SR (applied 09/2000):
It was about a year before I had to take a brush to the water line to clean off scum. Then it was about 2 years when I needed a diver every 6 months to scrub the bottom. Then it was 3 years before the bottom required painting. I thought this was pretty good life for bottom paint.
CA Trinidad SR (applied 08/2003):
$$$$$ (but that's boating no?). Within 6 months, I needed to take a brush to water line. Due to shaft problems, the boat was hauled last year in Aug.(08/2004) and bottom was power washed clean as standard practice at yard. Now (03/2005), water line is actively growing slime after ~18 months of paint application.
Granted, I've used the boat less this winter, but I think I'd get better mileage out of the SR stuff than this? Maybe I have too high of an expectation for $200.00 a gallon paint? I don't think so given prior experience with Trinidad SR.
All things being equal (same slip, same boat, same application procedure, etc.), I am tending to think the CA version of Trinidad SR is not as good as the other 49 states. HOWEVER, this is not to say Petit did not change the formula everywhere to save money/cut cost and be competitive (which is known to happen). On the other hand, I'm thinking it was 'dumbed' down to get CA EPA approval. Then again, I could be wrong.
Next time I'm purchasing out of area.......Shhhhhh.....
My $200.00 a gallon's worth (x 2!).
John M.
As an aside, just look at the silly new gasoline jerry jugs that were foisted upon us Californians by C.A.R.B. Although I have used them with no problems, many folks are breaking the nozzles off when filling tanks, spilling more fuel than before, and generally dislike them. I'm sticking to my old jugs. Maybe I need to start an 'old gas jerry jug' and 'good bottom paint' import business into CA. ?