Guest viewing is limited

Newport > Bermuda Race 2024 - and a friend's boat lost

Prairie Schooner

Jeff & Donna, E35-3 purchased 7/21
Newport-Bermuda 2024 start.jpg

From our perch on a hill at Fort Wetheril overlooking the passage out of Newport we had a good view of the 162 boat start. It was beautiful for the first couple hours and they had moderate wind. The boats were fighting a strong incoming tide which created some challenges, then a storm system came in which sucked the wind out and stranded some of the later starting boats for hours. From there we followed the race on YB Tracker.

Of most immediate note for us is the loss of J/122 “Alliance” which belonged to some acquaintances of ours. Thank God, all crew are safe. They describe the incident and rescue best themselves, here:
We know one of the crew pretty well, but haven’t had a chance to talk to him about it yet.
Also on crew was a young woman who is managing editor at Sail Magazine. She adds some additional detail here:

72’ racing sled, Proteus, dismasted less than twelve hours into the race. Speaking to our rigger, he heard it was a catastrophic compression failure of the carbon mast. Also, a Sweden 41 was abandoned due to ‘water ingress’ only about 80 miles from the finish. We haven’t heard any more about that. Some other boats retired due to gear failure or medical emergencies.

Stuff can happen out there. The good news is over 150 boats made it, they enjoyed some Bermuda hospitality, and have some great stories to tell.
 

Pete the Cat

Sustaining Member
If you crew on an ocean race, you would do well to judge your skipper and the prep by the standards of Alliance's skippers. Even with other boats in the near proximity, which is not always the case, these folks showed their skill in getting that many people off the boat and transferred without incident in an incredibly short time. They made assessments and decisions and organized spectacularly. I disagree with the skipper that they shortchanged the young crew by not completing the race--they showed them a much more important set of lessons that they will never forget. Thanks for posting this.
 

Prairie Schooner

Jeff & Donna, E35-3 purchased 7/21
If you crew on an ocean race, you would do well to judge your skipper and the prep by the standards of Alliance's skippers. Even with other boats in the near proximity, which is not always the case, these folks showed their skill in getting that many people off the boat and transferred without incident in an incredibly short time. They made assessments and decisions and organized spectacularly. I disagree with the skipper that they shortchanged the young crew by not completing the race--they showed them a much more important set of lessons that they will never forget. Thanks for posting this.
Ray, in case you haven't heard, it was a Tartan 37 that rescued the crew of the Sweden 41. Chalk one up for Team Tartan.
Newport-Bermuda 2024 rescue 2.jpg
- screen shot from Instagram
 

southofvictor

Member III
Blogs Author
Wow. Thanks for sharing these videos. Alliance’s owners seem like the epitome of preparedness and it paid off for them and their crew. The video of Ceilidh getting a line to the life raft is informative as to how the real world works in that type of situation. Plenty of lessons indeed.
 

Drewm3i

Marine Surveyor
Crazy that losing a rudder can sink a boat like that, but it looks like a pretty aggressive design (J/122).
 

Prairie Schooner

Jeff & Donna, E35-3 purchased 7/21
Crazy that losing a rudder can sink a boat like that, but it looks like a pretty aggressive design (J/122).
I haven't talked to anyone on the boat yet or even someone who had a first-hand conversation, but piecing together media accounts it sure sounds as if they hit something like a shipping container. That kind of mass striking the leverage of a long spade rudder could do a lot of damage. When I hear more, I'll recount it here.
 

Christian Williams

E381 - Los Angeles
Senior Moderator
Blogs Author
"Although they changed the fuel filter three times utilizing spares carried aboard, Bob Fye hypothesizes that the three days of heavy pounding on starboard tack dislodged enough sediment in the tank to repeatedly clog the suction tube located in the aft, port area of the fuel tank."

I think that before going offshore a fuel tank should be cleaned, which may require installation of access plates. Electronics can require battery charging by engine even with solar panels are installed. Probably not all that important coastwise, where if multiple filters don;t work there's always a port.

As printed in Ferenc Mate’s The World’s Best Sailboats (1986), Sweden Yachts had adopted an integrated, molded hull bottom framing grid (Figure 5), an innovation at that time introduced by Pedrick Yacht Designs in 1979 after a request from Ericson Yachts for a more robust method to provide structural stability across the hull. According to Pedrick, this arrangement is “a molded grid of hollow, integral transverse and 7 longitudinal ‘hat section’ framing… [with] ample contact area for bonding, consistency in materials and ease of manufacture.” It was quickly adopted by other manufacturers.

Interesting insight into the TAFG design introduced to Ericsons in the early 1980s.

The mast step in this boat apparently failed, injuring the hull. I think a possible lesson is that large holes should not be cut in the grid structure, especially near the mast step. The two ragged holes in the subject boat, each the size of a deck of cards, were apparently made to access hidden keel bolts. I continue to believe that small holes for drainage or wire runs do not significantly weaken our TAFG structure.

Upper rudder post bearing failure.

When the rudder of the subject boat struck a submerged object (if that's what happened) , the top bearing broke, allowing the post to angulate and damage the hull. Ericson rudder assemblies also have a top bearing secured only by machine screws. The Ericson top bearing fitting can become loose, which is not apparent from observing the deck plate. Inspection of the nuts needs to be from under the cockpit.

If a rudder does manage to strike something, it's going to bend the post or damage the hull. It seems to me that the only real answer to catastrophic rudder and hull damage by violent collision is a life raft and a satellite phone.

The subject boats were well maintained and crewed, and the excellent study a reminder of what can happen en route Bermuda, although not what probably will. Nothing beats a boat up like opposing wind and current when crossing t he Gulf Stream.
 

southofvictor

Member III
Blogs Author
It is impressive what only 1 knot of current against a 20 knot wind will do, let alone 3-4 knots. John Harries’ (who has a ton of experience in that part of the world) followup on the events found that as the primary takeaway - the importance of avoiding strong current vs wind conditions.

 
Top