"Let's not throw the Baby out with the bath water"
"Let's not throw the Baby out with the bath water", Is what my mechanic said.
Well at this point I am not going to replace the tank. Here's what we found. After removing that old copper tubing (yes copper), we found that it had black gunk in it, but I was easily able to blow that out. Then I checked to see if I could draw fuel directly from the tank, no go. My mechanic came down with his compressor and hooked it up directly to the tank. Removed the deck fill and gave it a couple very short blasts with the compressor and it blew out the clog. Then we hooked up a small hand pump and pumped out about a quart of fuel until it pumped clear. Pumped another half gallon to be on the safe side, still clear / clean fuel. I replaced the section of copper line with USCG-rated 3/8" rubber hose as well as new 3/8" barbs.
I took the boat out and ran it for and hour on Saturday and I swear I had more power than I ever did with my little 8.3 hp Yanmar 1GM10. My mechanic really wanted me to try and stir up the tank to see if I was pumping any more crud so I took advantage of every wake and wave I could find. I then put up the sails only to find my Genoa had some of the stitching coming undone on the hem of the leech, so I decided to cut my sea trial short and spent the rest of Saturday repairing the sail. I checked the Racor primary filter and the fuel was still clean as a whistle!
I got back on the water yesterday, the 5th and motored out for about and hour, still no problem. I hoisted the sails and sailed up the coast for about 3 hours and got a nice heel on in about 12 knots of wind, made a couple tacks to try to really stir up the tank. Then the wind died so I motored the six miles back (2 hrs), bashed through some pretty good wakes and still no problem. Once I rounded the Angels Gate lighthouse the typical Hurricane Gulch area was piping up to about 17 knots, there was a lot of wakes and chop in the harbor but I plowed right through at about 4.5 knots, 2600 rpm's, which is good speed for my boat with that kind of wind on the nose. Got back in my slip, I checked the Racor primary filter and the fuel was still clean as a whistle!
I also taped a piece of cloth to the end of a yard stick and stuck it down the deck fill and swished it around at the bottom of the tank and only found a little rust colored residue. So I think I am in good shape. I will do a couple more day sails and probably even replace the Racor primary filter one more time before I feel confident that things are okay to do another Catalina trip.
Oh yeah, after careful inspection of the tank and looking at how it was installed by my mechanic, he said that he would probably end up having to cut the tank up to remove it. I really don't want to have to go through that. Yes it's old, yes it's steel, but It does not leak and it seems to be pretty clean. We speculate that the clog started in that old twisted and kinked copper line and stuffed backed up all the way down into the tube inside the tank.
Thank you for all the replies and great advice through this ordeal! I'm back in action!